|
Introduction | Dissection Implications | Comparing Methods | The 3 Rs |
Opting in | Student Achievement | Online Resources | Other Alternatives
Comparing Methods
| Simulations & Models |
Disssection |
| Students can repeat the exercise until they get it correct |
If students make a mistake, the specimen is ruined. They can’t go back and try again. |
|
Students’ knowledge is tested at every step; students must show a grasp of the concepts before advancing. |
|
Difficult for the teacher to monitor every group of students; errors may not be caught until too late. |
|
Detailed information about organs, their functions and locations is available at the click of a mouse. |
|
Students may be too concerned with procedure to gain adequate knowledge about the organs. |
|
On-screen videos of actual dissections allow students a close-up look at the procedure. |
|
Demonstrations by the teacher may not be easily seen by all students. |
|
Programs can be edited to meet specific students needs without other students' knowledge. |
|
All students need to complete the same dissection procedure, resulting in some students feeling frustrated. |
|
Once the software is installed there is no further set-up needed. Students who miss a lab due to illness can make it up at any time. |
|
Lab supplies and utensils must be set out before every lab, and cleaned and put away afterwards. Difficult for a student to make up a missed lab. |
|
Students can learn about biology without feeling they are responsible for an animal’s death or adding to the diminishment of a species. |
|
Students may act out during a dissection lab - often because they don’t know how to express their ethical concerns, or don’t feel comfortable enough to express their feelings appropriately. |
|
Costs are kept low since the software can be used year after year. Compared to the cost of prepared specimens, software pays for itself in one to three years. |
|
Preserved specimens must be purchased every year for each pair of students; prices can vary and usually increase each year. |
|
|
 |